Grant and I are finished with Angel, which has left a bit of a vacuum in our nightly "watch something and cuddle" routine. (You can only watch the latest BSG so many times...) We've been catching up on Smallville, but I also turned on LotS to see what he'd think. So far it's basically the same impression I have: there's a bit of a quality cap, since you can only get so good with the source material. We're also both a little confused by some of the changes they've made to the universe -- as much as I keep repeating to myself "It's a re-imagining, not an adaptation", I also keep saying things like "Why the hell isn't Darken Rahl blond?!"
Individually, though, some episode reactions:
1x03 Bounty: In which we learn that random mapmakers can do magic stuff, and otherwise the episode is filler. It's interesting to see how many people in the Midlands are discontent with Darken Rahl; the only people in the Midlands we really met in Wizard's First Rule were people who were of direct, immediate use to Richard and Kahlan. It also feels strange to have "filler" episodes when the plot is so long and convoluted. I'm not going to be surprised at all when they cut out certain elements of the book (I suspect Du Chaillu and the Mud People are going to be completely left behind), but it surprises me that they'd rather make filler episodes than actually follow the plot.
1x04 Brennidon: This is another one of those episodes that makes me go "WTF?" Richard's entire family situation has changed; his mother was caught in a town but later escaped, what? He had an adoptive father and mother? I suppose this one does more to establish Richard as the best hope of the Midlands, but the family stuff is downright weird. Oh hey, and this is the episode where Richard Stands Up For A Town Who Then Stands Up For Him (something we see often in fantasy/sci-fi series). Nice to see they're still doing stock plots? I guess?
1x05 Listener: Wow, this is a kind of magic we never saw in the books. A kid who can read minds? (I also feel obliged to point out that this is the "magic kid" episode. Stock plots FTW! Or something.) Yet again it's a filler episode, the third in a row that does nothing to advance the main plot. I'm totally nonplussed by the suggestion that Kahlan's father a.) outlived her mother and b.) used Kahlan and her sister to do evil things -- wait, what? What? That just seems wrong, and giving Kahlan a tortured childhood seems unnecessary. Also, I note that the kid is trying to 'ship Richard and Kahlan. Ha! Don't worry, kid, they'll get there. They'll get there!
I think people who have read the books and know just how much is coming are doomed to be a little confused as we watch these episodes; we keep wondering why they're not getting on with it. Meanwhile, people just watching the series may realize that there's a plot, but aren't in any hurry to get along with it -- it's actually not standard for series to have a driving plot start-to-finish, with few to no filler episodes. Even shows that do have a driving plot are mostly episodic in their first few season, perhaps because they're not sure if they're going to be renewed and don't necessarily want to have a series cliffhanger by default.
Like last time, I'm really fond of Kahlan. I'm thrilled to see how competent and smart she is, and I love watching her fight. She makes good, solid, reasonable decisions, and she has her own reasons for following Richard (even if we're not 100% sure what they are yet; why Richard? Is it just prophecy, or is there more to it?). We also haven't seen her use her powers since the premiere, which I think is good -- we don't want to become too reliant on them, and I definitely want to hear more about them rather than picking everything up in bits and pieces from short-lived mind-controlled thugs. Also, Bridget Regan is both adorable and hot, and despite the horror of the series (and you know there's going to be more), she finds reasons to smile fairly often. This is a good thing. ^_^
Tags: fantasy, sword of truth, television
If some of my favorite books were made into TV shows, I'd probably go back and reread the books before watching them. In this case? Not so much. I did re-read the Sword of Truth series last year, as I'd not read the final, concluding book, and wanted to be done with the series. A quick summary of my thoughts:
- Wizard's First Rule: Not bad at all! Neat world!
- Stone of Tears: Wow, this is really violent. Okay. Neat world.
- Blood of the Fold: What is with all the violence? The world's still kind of cool. Oh, wow! That villain from the first book is awesome now! Yay!
- Temple of the Winds: Didn't we all think this was the coolest book ever when we first read it? Why was that again? Hello, violence against women. Wait, does every woman really get threatened with rape over the course of the series? Hmm. Okay, done now...
- Soul of the Fire: In which we discover that Terry Goodkind doesn't like the Clintons. Also, yeah, I guess his female characters are just kinda doomed to sexual harassment and assault. ALL OF THEM. O_O
- Faith of the Fallen: I *ow* already *OW* own *ow* a copy of *OW OW* Atlas Shrugged! I *ow* read it *ow* in college! *OW* You don't *ow* have to *ow* beat me over the *OW OW OW* head with it! OW! STOP THAT!
- The Pillars of Creation: Who are these people and why do I care? ...ow. Hey, sneak attack from Atlas Shrugged. PUT THAT DOWN.
- Naked Empire: In which it is explained to us why we have to go fight Iraq. Wait, were we still in the Sword of Truth series? Oh, we were? Really? Okay...
- Chainfire: WHOA. Okay. Cool concept.
- Phantom: I... think we just did this in the last book?
- Confessor: JESUS CHRIST WOULD YOU STOP WITH THE RAPE THREATS AND RAPE SCENES ALREADY. NO, REALLY. I GET THE POINT. The point being "bad guys rape women" and, apparently, "really heroic women don't get raped, because the bad guys can't bear to assault their heroic virtue". I think I just threw up in my mouth a little. (When you can learn a thing or two about treating women like human beings from the Mike Harmon books by John Ringo...) Also, OMGWTFBBQpolarbear ending? Huh?
So in all fairness to the TV series, I'm approaching it with some curiosity and some pretty low expectations. Working from the source material, it can only be so good. That said, it's more a revisioning of the story than an actual word-for-word translation, and it's interesting seeing what gets changed.
The guy they've cast to play Richard is Craig Horner, a guy who's 25 and seriously doesn't look it. On one hand, I keep looking at him thinking, "Oh, he's way too young..." On the other hand, he's older than Richard is really supposed to be in the series right now. QQ! Apparently I'm the old one.
The actress cast as Kahlan (Bridget Regan) is awesome. She can act, she's lovely, and she kicks all manner of ass. \o/ I am very pleased -- now I just hope the series as a whole is good to her, because she really needs to continue that level of asskickery and takecareofmyselfitude in order to have me not throw things at the TV.
Jury's still out on Zedd. I'm predisposed to like both Chase (Jay Laga'aia) and the guy who plays Darken Rahl (Craig Parker), though it's throwing me for a loop that he's not blond. Parker looks just fine blond! Didn't you guys cast him because of Lord of the Rings?
As for the show itself, a quick, spoilery rundown:
Tags: fantasy, sword of truth, television